I was super excited to receive a rare buy one get one free store coupon for Maybelline face or lip cosmetics when I scanned my card at the CVS Coupon Center this week. The coupon is also available to select users in the app. Download the app now to see if you received this coupon. It pairs nicely with the promotion on Maybelline this week: receive $5 ExtraBucks when you buy two.

I was able to test the BOGO store coupon on Maybelline FitMe blush, which was the lowest-priced face or lip cosmetic available at my store. Maybelline Baby Lips were out of stock, so I can’t confirm if this coupon will work on that product. I had a $1.50 digital Maybelline face cosmetic manufacturer coupon clipped, and it did deduct from my transaction. It adjusted the value of the store coupon down, though. It does not appear the register will stack the two.

These deals are available in stores only.

Buy 2, receive $5 ExtraBucks through Oct. 24, limit 3

Use one BOGO Free – Maybelline Face or Lip Cosmetic, CVS Store Coupon from the CVS Coupon Center or CVS App

Pay $5.99, receive $5 ExtraBucks

Final Price: $0.50 each, when you buy 2

If you don’t have the BOGO store coupon, you can still stock up on Maybelline for up to a $0.62 moneymaker.

Use one $3.00/1 Maybelline New York Eye product, limit 1 (maybelline.com)

And use one $1.00/1 Maybelline New York Eye product, limit 1 (coupons.com)

Pay $4.38, receive $5 ExtraBucks

Final Price: $0.62 Moneymaker, when you buy 2

Buy 1 Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow $4.19, regular price

Use one $3.00/1 Maybelline New York Eye product, limit 1 (maybelline.com)

And use one $1.50/1 Maybelline New York Face product, limit 1 (coupons.com)

Pay $5.68, receive $5 ExtraBucks

Final Price: $0.34 each, when you buy 2

Buy 1 Maybelline Expert Wear Eyeshadow $4.19, regular price

Use one $3.00/1 Maybelline New York Eye product, limit 1 (maybelline.com)

And use one $2.00/1 Maybelline New York Face product from RMN Oct. 18

Pay $5.18, receive $5 ExtraBucks

Final Price: $0.09 each, when you buy 2

SHOP ALL CVS DEALS HERE