Finding good prices on home furnishings and decor can be quite a challenge. And when it comes to the warehouse club stores, there is always the battle of which club store is better. So let’s check out some barstools at BJ’s Warehouse, Sam’s Club and Costco and see who comes out on top! Please note: shipping costs for Sam’s Club are estimates as prices will vary according to delivery location.

Up first, the Home Meridian Kelsey Barstool from BJ’s Warehouse. At $129.99, this black faux leather and chrome stool comes with a curved back, sleek footrest and sturdy base. And with shipping included, it’s not that bad of a price—until you see that Costco’s Monterrey Barstool sells for just $99.99, shipping included, for 2 stools! Nearly identical in appearance, this set, with its 62% savings, is a true winner.

Savings: $159.99 or 62% on 2 stools

Next in the lineup is the Rochester 26″ Barstool, also from Costco. This beautiful stool sports sand-colored fabric edged with nailhead trim and perched on a dark finished-wood base. But this 2-pack of stools sells for $599.99, with shipping included, thankfully. Enter Sam’s Club—their matchup comes in the form of these Garrett Counter Height Dining Chairs, a 2-pack set of stools that bears remarkable similarity, but with a much more appealing $174.99 price tag. And even with approximately $13.00 in shipping costs, it’s still a 69% savings!

Savings: $412.00 or 69% on 2 stools

And last but certainly not least, our battle finishes with Sam’s Club’s Fleming Bar Stools. Again, sold as a 2-pack, this brown padded leather seat comes fully assembled, and complete with a brass footplate. But you’ll pay $476.00 plus approximately $31.00 in shipping for this duo. Heading to Costco would be the way to go here. Their Bronson 30″ Barstool comes in a set of 2. And while they lack the brass footplate, their sales price of just $219.99, including shipping, will score a 57% savings!

Savings: $287.01 or 57% on 2 stools

Knockout Knockoffs: The Battle of the Warehouse Club Barstools