We're reader-supported and only partner with brands we trust. When you buy through links on our site we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn More. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date and time indicated and are subject to change.
Microwaved pizza is super gross. But reheating pizza in your conventional or even toaster oven takes wayyyyyy too long. It’s a real conundrum. Often the decision comes down to this question, “Just how hungry are you?” But wait, it’s 2023 and we have a solution! You can use your air fryer to reheat your pizza in a snap. Unlike rubbery microwave pizza, air fryer pizza is delicious.
Think it can’t get any better? You can even cook frozen pizza in your air fryer. This is a game changer when you want a pie but have zero interest in heating your entire oven.
How to Reheat Pizza in an Air Fryer
Now, let’s get down to business. Here are our step-by-step tips for bringing that leftover pizza back to life.
1. Line your air fryer tray.
As your pizza reheats, the cheese is going to melt. To prevent it from burning to the bottom of your air fryer tray, you can use a piece of parchment.
But one of the appeals of reheating pizza in an air fryer is that you get a crispier crust. If that’s your goal, try using aluminum foil instead of parchment paper.
2. Add water to the outer air fryer basket.
Just because you want crispy crust doesn’t mean you want dry crust. Adding a bit of water to the outer basket of your air fryer can help replace any moisture the bread loses with all that heat.
Related: Avoid the top 10 most common air fryer mistakes.
3. Place your pizza slices.
With all that melty cheese, it’s important to make sure that your pizza slices aren’t touching. You don’t want to stack them either, or they’ll end up fusing together.
For most air fryers this means cooking one to two slices at a time. If you have a larger full-size air fryer, you should be able to fit more. Remember that the same rule applies, though: Make sure the slices aren’t touching.
4. Cook at 350 – 380 degrees.
Here’s where you’ll have to experiment a little bit, as not all air fryers cook exactly the same — especially not in all locations. Altitude can affect cook times.
If your fryer tends to run hot, start out by cooking at 350 degrees. If you know it tends to do the opposite, the max temperature you want to experiment with is 380 degrees.
For thin crust pizzas, start checking progress around the 3-minute mark. Depending on your fryer, you may need more time. Just check on it about every minute until you learn the nuances of your own air fryer’s cook times.
For thicker crusts, you’re usually safe making the first check at four minutes.
TIP: These temperatures are in Fahrenheit. If you’re cooking in Celsius, the range is about 177 – 193 degrees.
5. Cool and enjoy!
Your air fryer will legitimately cook your pizza, so don’t forget that hot cheese can be scalding. Give your reheated pizza a beat to cool before enjoying the best reheated pizza you’ve ever had in such a short cook time.
Air Fryer Pizza FAQs
Here are answers to your most commonly asked air fryer pizza questions.
Is pizza better reheated in the oven or an air fryer?
It’s a matter of personal preference. If you like crispier crust, you’ll probably prefer the air fryer. The air fryer is also a lot quicker when it comes to reheating pizza, so if you don’t have a lot of time on your hands, it’s a better option.
How long does it take to reheat pizza in an air fryer?
Cook times are going to vary from model to model, but most of the time, it takes just three to four minutes to reheat your pizza in an air fryer.
Do I need to use oil?
You can if you want, but pizza is plenty greasy enough on its own. Oil optional for this item.
Should I preheat the air fryer?
That all depends on your model. Be sure to read the instruction booklet that came with your air fryer to learn if you have to spend any energy on preheating.
Can you cook frozen pizza in an air fryer?
Yes! And you’ll use roughly the same temperature. Personal pizzas usually take about the same time to cook, about four to six minutes.
You will probably need a little longer for french bread pizzas. Try starting around seven minutes and checking on your dish every couple minutes after that until your learn your individual air fryer’s optimal cook time.
No air fryer? Here are some deals.
If you haven’t yet joined the air fryer craze and need the appliance to get you started, we have some ideas. Check out these options: