Aline Henman | Updated

CoverGirl Eye Pencils, $4.02 Moneymaker at CVS

The Krazy Coupon Lady is an ad-supported service. Many offers on our site contain affiliate links, and we may earn a small commission if you make a purchase using them. Some posts are sponsored by the maker of the product, and we receive a fee for the post. See our full advertiser disclosure.

Tag:dealformula
There’s a chance to make over $4 buying CoverGirl at CVS this week thanks to an ExtraBucks promotion, new manufacturer coupons, and a Mystery Offer store coupon stack. There are two different promotions running on CoverGirl: receive $5 ExtraBucks when you buy two, and receive $8 ExtraBucks when you buy three. For the best deal, you’ll want to pick up three items to earn the $8 ExtraBucks. Keep in mind that this means you’ll need three different copies of the Jan. 8 SmartSource newspaper insert. There’s a new $3/1 CoverGirl coupon inside. Combine it with the $2 CoverGirl Mystery Offer to score a $4.02 moneymaker buying CoverGirl Perfect Blend eye pencils.

A Mystery Offer is a store coupon that’s advertised in the weekly ad and is available to all existing ExtraCare members. It’ll be available to clip in the CVS store mobile app, or you can stop by the red Coupon Center to print a paper copy in store. The coupon isn’t available to use on online purchases. Learn more about how to coupon at CVS.

As mentioned, you’ll need three copies of the Jan. 8 SmartSource insert to receive the best deal. SmartSource (SS) is a coupon insert that comes with most Sunday newspapers. Newspaper coupons can sometimes vary by region. Did you know you can buy Sunday newspapers at the dollar store? Check out more ways to get free Sunday newspaper coupons.

I used the CoverGirl Perfect Blend eye pencils in this scenario because they’re regularly priced at just $4.99. Please note that regular prices may vary by store. Additionally, this is just an option to get a freebie. You can still score a great deal on items you may actually need. Mix and match your favorite products, but keep in mind that your final price may vary from this example scenario.

Text CVS to 57299 and be the first to know about the best CVS deals.

MORE HOT CVS DEALS THIS WAY

18-Piece Fragrance Sampler Set at Macy's, as Low as $15
macy's fragrance
macy's fragrance
Macy’s Black Friday Starts Now — Shop Their Biggest Deals Yet
macys-black-friday-featured-image-2
macys-black-friday-featured-image-2
Kohl's Black Friday Is Here: Find the Hottest Deals, Plus Get a 15% Off Code
kohls-black-friday-featured-image-live-2025-1
kohls-black-friday-featured-image-live-2025-1
Craftsy Is Basically Free — 1 Year of Craft Tutorials for Only 25 Cents
craftsy
craftsy
Stack Codes at Under Armour and Save Up to 81%: $30 Shoes, $8 Hat, and More
Under Armour retail shorts section jan 1
Under Armour retail shorts section jan 1
This 10.1-Inch Smart Digital Calendar Is $66 With Amazon Promo (Was $200)
Mother and daughter using the flyEVfish Digital Calendar, 10.1 Inch Smart Electronic Desk Calendar.
Mother and daughter using the flyEVfish Digital Calendar, 10.1 Inch Smart Electronic Desk Calendar.
Huggies Diapers on Sale at Costco — As Low as $26.99 per Box
costco-huggies-diapers
costco-huggies-diapers
Adult Shoe Sale at Macy's — Get Boots, Sneakers, and More for Just $19.99
macys-retail-shoes-womens-boots-black-friday-2025
macys-retail-shoes-womens-boots-black-friday-2025
K-Cup Coffee Pod Boxes, as Low as $19.99 Each at Staples
hand holding 44 ct dunkin k-cups
hand holding 44 ct dunkin k-cups