Our team at The Krazy Coupon Lady has been tracking pumpkin prices for years, and here's the deal: You shouldn't be paying more than $0.40 per pound for pumpkins, period. But this year, you can do way better than that.
We hit up every major store to find out who's got the best prices on pumpkins in 2025. Pro tip: always weigh your options when stores charge flat rates since you might find a heavier pumpkin for the same price — you could even bring your own bathroom scale along.
Want alerts on more Halloween deals and seasonal savings? Download the KCL app for free now, and we'll remind you when the best deals drop.
Quick Price Comparison
Where to Find the Best Deals on Pumpkins Right Now
1. Walmart, $3.97 on sale
Best Price: $0.22 - $0.28 per pound
Walmart wins this year with pumpkins weighing 14 - 18 pounds on sale for $3.97. That's the lowest per-pound price I found. Even at the regular $4.50 price point without the sale, they're competitive.
2. Albertsons, $4.68
Best Price: $0.31 - $0.47 per pound
Albertsons switched from per-pound pricing to a flat rate this year: $4.68 for medium pumpkins. If you can find one of the heavier pumpkins in the 15-pound range, you'll pay just $0.31 per pound — one of the best deals around. But if you grab a lighter 10-pounder, you'll be closer to $0.47 per pound. The key here is hunting for the biggest pumpkin in the bin.
KCL TIP: You can clip a digital coupon in the Albertsons app and get $5 off a pumpkin with the purchase of a 42-count Frito-Lay Chips Multipack. This offer is good through Oct. 28.
3. Aldi, $3.95
Best Price: $0.33 per pound
Aldi dropped their price from around $4.49 last year to $3.95 this year — a 12% decrease. Their pumpkins average 12 pounds, making this a solid deal for medium-sized carving pumpkins.
4. Costco, $7.99
Best Price: $0.33 per pound
Want a big pumpkin? Costco's 24-pounders are your best bet at just $0.33 per pound. Perfect for giant jack-o'-lanterns if your store still has some in stock.
5. Target, $5.49
Best Price: $0.37 per pound
Target's 15-pound pumpkins come in at $0.37 per pound. Not the cheapest, but a good deal if you're already shopping there, and you can pay with a Circle Card to get a 5% discount.
6. Kroger, $6 ($5 on sale)
Best Price: $0.38 per pound
Take advantage of Kroger's sale price on 13-pound pumpkins to get pay $5 apiece. Look for the biggest pumpkin in the pile to get the best price per pound.
7. Meijer, $5.99 ($4.99 on sale)
Best Price: $0.38 per pound
Meijer's pumpkins average about 13 pounds at $5.99, which works out to $0.46 per pound, the same as Kroger. But they're on sale through Oct. 28 for $4.99, which brings your cost down to about $0.38 per pound. If you're shopping at Meijer anyway, it's a decent deal.
8. Sam's Club, $6.96 ($5.96 on sale)
Best Price: $0.40 per pound
Sam's Club pumpkins weigh 13 - 15 pounds and are priced at $6.96, but if your store still has them in stock, look for a sale price of $5.96. At the sale price, you'll pay $0.40 - $0.46 per pound depending on which pumpkin you grab. It's right at that $0.40 threshold we recommend, so it's not the best deal, but acceptable if you're already stocking up on other warehouse club items.
9. Whole Foods, $7.99
Best Price: $0.40 per pound
Whole Foods' pumpkins in the 15 - 20 pound range are priced at $7.99, which works out to $0.40 - $0.53 per pound. If you can grab one of the heavier 20-pounders, you'll hit that $0.40 sweet spot. Just avoid their tiny 5-pound pumpkins, which cost $1.99 per pound (or $1.49 with Prime), which is way too expensive.
Pricing Strategy: Flat Rate vs. per Pound
In 2025, most stores charge one price for pumpkins, regardless of size. This means your strategy depends on what you're looking for. If you need small pumpkins under 10 pounds, stick with Aldi or Walmart's cheapest flat rates. But if you're after big 20-plus-pounders (see my size examples below), Costco's flat pricing gives you the best value since you're getting way more pumpkin for your money.
Here's something most people don't know: pumpkins are grouped by size tier, not exact weight. That means you might find a 13-pound and a 17-pound pumpkin sitting in the same bin, both priced at $5.99. Always pick up a few and compare weights. Choosing the heavier one can save you $0.10 - $0.15 per pound, which really adds up if you're buying multiple pumpkins.
Stores to Skip (Where Pumpkins Are Pricey)
Home Depot's pumpkins run anywhere from $0.62 - $1.06 per pound, which is overpriced compared to grocery stores.
Lowe's is even worse at $0.87 - $1.16 per pound. You're basically paying double what you should.
And while Whole Foods has decent prices on their larger pumpkins at $0.40 - $0.53 per pound, avoid their small 5-pound pumpkins that'll cost you $1.99 per pound (or $1.49 with Prime). That's just not worth it.
When to Buy Pumpkins
You'll find the best selection in early to mid-October when stores are fully stocked. If you're willing to gamble a bit, prices can drop 20% - 30% in the days right before Halloween as stores try to clear out inventory. Just know that you're risking slim pickings if you wait too long.
Related Reading:
