Brynne Conroy | 

Hobby Lobby vs. Joann vs. Michaels: Who Has the Best Prices?

The Krazy Coupon Lady is an independent service supported by advertising. Most of the offers appearing on our site are from companies from which we receive compensation. We may receive a small payment from an affiliate if you click a link to purchase a product. Sometimes a post is sponsored by the maker of the product, and we receive a fee for the post. Learn More.

If you’re a fan of crafting, then you’ve probably stepped foot inside all three stores that make up the craft-store trifecta: Michaels, Joann, and Hobby Lobby. But just because you’re a craft fiend doesn’t mean you know which one is the cheapest craft store. Or which retailer has the trendiest home decor or the best coupon policy.

That’s why I decided to do a little digging. One thing I can tell you right off the bat is that whether I’m buying paint supplies from Michaels, fabric and quilting supplies from Joann, or home decor and jewelry-making kits from Hobby Lobby, I always aim to get everything at least 30% off at all three stores. Knowing each store’s sale cycles and coupons is a big part of getting the absolute best prices and finding the cheapest craft store for every project.

Read on for the low down on which craft store of the three has the best prices on yarn, picture frames, holiday decorations, and more.

For more money-saving deals, tips, and coupons download The Krazy Coupon Lady app or text HACKS to 57299.

 

For the most part, Hobby Lobby has the cheapest prices on craft items.

We price-compared a few different craft items and found that Hobby Lobby often has the lowest prices. Check it out:

ProductJoannMichaelsHobby Lobby
Fabric
100% Cotton, Gingham$9.99/yd$6.99/yd$5.99/yd
100% Polyester Fleece, Solid$12.99/yd$7.49 – $8.99/yd$7.99/yd
Scrapbooking
1″ Paper Punch$13.99$9.99$4.49
12″x12″ Smooth Cardstock$0.79/sheet$0.99/sheet$0.79/sheet
Knitting & Crochet
Crochet Thread 400 yds, #10$4.99 Aunt Lydia’s$4.99 Aunt Lydia’s$2.99 Artiste
Yarn, 100% Acrylic, 6-oz Skein$5.49 Caron Simply Soft$5.99 Caron Simply Soft$4.99 Bee Soft Secret
Ribbon
Satin Solid 1.5″$9.49/21 yds ($0.45/yd)$4.99/3 yds ($1.66/yd)$3.99/3 yds ($1.33/yd)
Faux Linen 2.5″$4.99/4 yds($1.25/yd)$9.99/8.3 yds ($1.20/yd)$4.99/4 yds ($1.25/yd)
Baking
White Paper Cups$3.29/48 ($0.07/cup)$4.49/100 cups ($0.05/cup)$5.99/200 cups ($0.03/cup)
Rainbow Nonpareils$5.99/7.5 oz ($0.80/oz)$4.99/4 oz ($1.25/oz)$4.99/17.63 oz ($0.28/oz)
Storage
Plastic Organizer$10.99 for 36 sections ($0.31/section)$14.99 for 32 sections ($0.47/section)$4.99 for 28 sections ($0.18/section)
Photo Storage Box, Black$5.49 (10.75″x7.37″x4.25″), or $0.16/cubic inch$7.99 (11.2″x7.8″x4.5″), or $0.02/cubic inch$4.99 (11″x7.5″x4.25″), or $0.01/cubic inch
Decor
Lamb’s Ear Wreath$49.99 (21″)$65.99 (22″)$34.99 (22″)

 

 

1. But Joann wins the coupon challenge because you can stack and use competitor coupons!

A JoAnn employee handing a coupon to a customer over the checkout counter

It’s true — Joann accepts Michaels’ coupons. Really, they accept all competitor coupons, but Michaels is their big competitor. (Especially since Hobby Lobby doesn’t issue coupons at all anymore.)

Subscribe to Joann emails and download the Joann app for iPhone or Android to get exclusive high-value discounts (like 60% off any regular-priced item).

Related: If you’re a regular Joann shopper, be sure to study our Joann sales and hacks.

 

2. You can always find a Michaels coupon good for 20% – 30% off one regular-priced item.

Michaels.com basically always has a promo code that will earn you 20% – 30% off any regular-priced item (at the time of publication, it was DAILY23US for 20% off). You can find it right on the coupon page or in the Michaels app.

A word to the wise: In early 2020, Michaels revised their coupon policy and stopped accepting competitor coupons, but they will price match if the exact same product is cheaper at Joann or Hobby Lobby.

Related: We assembled all of the best Michaels sales and saving strategies.

 

3. Hobby Lobby loses on couponing, but everything (and I mean everything) goes on sale.

a person holding up a hobby lobby sale flyer

Hobby Lobby did away with their 40% off coupon in March 2021, and they don’t accept competitor coupons. So, they lose the couponing game. Hobby Lobby claims this move allows them to do more storewide discounts, which can be found via their Weekly Ad.

New ads drop every Monday and run through Saturday. Expect sales ranging from 30% – 50% off across a wide range of departments including home decor, craft books, yarn, paper crafts, fabric, jewelry making, and furniture. Items rotate on a weekly basis. The one bummer: Hobby Lobby doesn’t price match.

TIP: Technically, if you’re shopping Hobby Lobby online, you’ll get access to the sales a day earlier on Sunday. But we highly recommend not shopping Hobby Lobby online — their shipping fees are ridiculous.

 

4. Get seriously discounted patterns at Joann or Hobby Lobby.

Never pay full price for a pattern. Ever.

Simplicity, Butterick, and McCall patterns are regularly priced between $11 to $23 but often go on sale for $0.99, 10 for $10, or $1.29 each at Joann.

Vogue patterns can cost up to $35, but you’ll see Joann mark these down to just $5.

 

5. Joann is the queen of fabric (and fabric discounts)!

a person holding up fabric at joann fabrics

Joann is the queen of fabric, and Hobby Lobby is a close second (standard sales are 40% off every other week, with seasonal fabrics at 50% off.)

Vow to never pay full price at Joann — always shoot for 40% to 50% off whatever cut of fabric you need. Your patience will (literally) pay off in the end.

Yes, you can use a coupon on your fabric purchase at Joann, but the sale prices are often just as good. When there’s a fabric sale, remember to use a percentage-off-your-total-purchase coupon and stock up!

Check out our optimal price guide for popular fabrics:

  • Flannel: 50% – 70% off at Joann (look for 70% off in November).
  • Minky: 40% off at Hobby Lobby (every other week).
  • Cotton: 40% off at Hobby Lobby (every other week), or wait for a 40% off sale at Joann.
  • Tulle: Wait for Joann “3 yards for $4” sale (there’s one in March).
  • Fleece: 50% – 60% off at Joann (look for 50% off in February).
  • Home decor fabrics: 40% off at Joann (look for the sale in May and August).
  • Licensed character fabric: 40% off — the biggest selection is at Joann (look for the sale in the first week of May).
  • Quilt batting: 50% off at Joann.

TIP: Get the full Joann Fabrics sale schedule.

 

 

6. Get scrapbook supplies from Hobby Lobby, unless Joann is running their 10/$2 promotion.

Hobby Lobby’s scrapbook selection is arguably the most modern of all the cheapest craft stores, and the company regularly runs 40% off sales on papercraft and scrapbooking supplies every other week. Specific deals rotate, but Hobby Lobby employees told me that Tim Holtz products, single sheets, and planner stickers go on sale at least every other week.

But when you see Joann mark down their scrapbook paper to 10/$2, it’s time to shop Joann for scrapbook supplies instead. These sales happen three or four times per year.

 

7. Michaels wins for their picture frame selection and discount. Buy when you see 50% off.

A woman looking at picture frames inside Michaels

The framing selection at Michaels just can’t be beat. If there isn’t a 50% off sale going on, getting 40% off frames is still a bargain. In case you don’t see any deals listed under the website’s coupon tab, check the “Online Deals” section, where I found 40% off Aaron Brothers Frame Collections.

Michaels also offers an everyday sale on custom frames that ranges from 65% – 70% savings on the entire purchase (the frame plus the service).

 

8. Joann is the best place to find 30% off craft books.

Joann used to be a real one when it came to craft books with their 50% off sales. Their book sales only hit 30% off nowadays, but Joann still takes the top spot of cheapest craft store in this area for one crucial reason: Craft book sales don’t really exist at the other stores.

One Michaels employee told me he’s never put crafting or quilting books on sale. Hobby Lobby has sales of around 40% – 50% off memoirs, Christian books, and self-help titles, but nothing that’ll help you on your next project.

Although Michaels boasts a solid in-store selection of products, I found that most options were not available to purchase online. The opposite was true with Joann.

One more thing: Those Michaels coupon codes we told you about? I was never able to successfully apply them to a book purchase.

At Joann, I was able to buy Encyclopedia of Classic Quilt Patterns for 40% off regular price by stacking an online promo code to an existing sale. Final price: $15.05.

 

9. Give Michaels a slight edge on their crochet thread.

a person holding crochet thread at michaels

When it comes to the basics, Michaels and Joann are practically identical. Both stores typically price Aunt Lydia’s Classic Crochet Thread at $4.99, and both Joann and Michaels allow you to use a percentage off promo code on your purchase.

Michaels pulls away slightly only because I found more brand variety and had better luck buying in bulk — especially online, where Joann had only a few bulk options.

Hobby Lobby is the spot if you’re into micro crochet, though. One week each month, you’ll find thread 30% off, which makes this multi-color thread set $13.29.

 

10. Skip Hobby Lobby’s yarn. Go to Joann or Michaels instead.

Both Joann and Michaels offer an excellent selection of high-quality yarn. (If you don’t care about quality wool yarn, head to Walmart for cheaper polyester blends.)

Look for Caron Super Soft skeins to go on sale at Joann for $4.99 and Everyday Cotton Yarn by Loops & Threads to hit $2.99 at Michaels. Both stores regularly have sales on Bernat Blanket Yarn, but watch the size. Joann will often offer better prices on bigger skeins.

TIP: See a yarn sale in the Michaels flyer? Read the fine print. Michaels is notorious for putting “50% off Yarn!” in big letters, so you think every brand is on sale. But most of the time it’ll only be for one or two brands while the rest is either full price or a disappointing 10% off.

 

 

11. Get 50% off ribbon every week at Hobby Lobby.

A woman's hand holding four rolls of bright colored ribbon in different patterns

Every single week, you’ll see the type of ribbon sale rotate at Hobby Lobby.

Solid-colored and patterned ribbon by the spool — including faux fur options — will be 50% off one week, and the next week, trim ribbon by the yard will be 50% off. Time your ribbon purchase based on what you need.

Related: Hack the system with our guide to the Hobby Lobby Sale Schedule.

 

12. Buy premium threads like Sulky and Gütermann for 50% off at Joann.

Depending on your machine, the more affordable Coats & Clark brand thread will work for you.

But if you need premium brands like Sulky and Gütermann, you can find them at Michaels — but for a consistently higher price. Fortunately, Joann stocks these brands, and it’s normal to find these products on sale for 50% off. Be sure to use your highest-value coupon from either Michaels or Joann to bring the price down.

The same goes for embroidery or bobbin thread, but wait for either a BOGO free or 50% off sale.

Related: Now through December 31, 2023, you can score a National Sewing Circle premium membership for just $2.

 

13. Use a coupon on clearance seasonal decor and crafts at Joann and Michaels.

a hand holding up three joann fabrics coupons

Each store has their own seasonal decor markdown schedule, but they’re all similar. The merchandise starts at 40% off and inches up from there every week until it hits 90% off after the holiday.

But, you can use a percentage-off-your-total-purchase coupon on these clearance items at Joann and Michaels when they’re available.

Related: Here’s your guide to the After-Christmas Clearance Schedule at all the top stores.

 

14. Hobby Lobby is cutting in on Joann’s button game.

Joann used to be the undisputed button champion, but lately Hobby Lobby has taken a shot at the throne. At Joann, keep an eye out for BOGO free and 50% off sales. Joann’s sales happen a few times a year. If your timing doesn’t line up, though, remember that buttons at Joann are coupon-friendly.

Hobby Lobby will sometimes put buttons on sale for $0.99 – $1.99, which — depending on the item you are purchasing — can be better or worse than Joann’s 50% off pricing. For example, if it’s regularly priced at $1.49, the Joann 50% off sale price would be better. But if it normally retails for $3.49 and Hobby Lobby has it on sale for $0.99, scoop that deal up!

The word from a Michaels employee was that she had never seen a sale on this item in the year she has worked at the store.

 

15. Look for 50% off jewelry-making supplies at Hobby Lobby every two out of three weeks.

a person shopping at hobby lobby

Hobby Lobby’s jewelry-making selection is vast. Expect to find everything you’d need for a jewelry-making class — but don’t expect it to be on sale all at one time.

I was told that it can take as long as three weeks for everything to make its way to the sale rack. Once it’s there, you’re looking at savings of 50%.

 

 

16. Head to Joann for the top deals on craft machines.

Across the board, sewing machines or craft machines (like Cricuts) are listed as coupon exclusions at all the cheapest craft stores.

That said, you’ll still catch good sales on Cricut machines at Joann, especially around the holidays. That’s when I found a Cricut Explore Air 2 for $179.99 — a full $20 cheaper than the best sale I saw at Michaels and $70 cheaper than its regular price.

I only recommend buying sewing machines if you’re looking for beginner-level machines, as higher-quality machines rarely go on sale. If simple works for you, then wait for Hobby Lobby to put sewing machines on sale (they go on sale once per month).

TIP: When getting your machine cleaned, smaller local shops typically have a shorter waiting period. Joann will often have an eight-week wait, while smaller shops can get your machine up and running within the week.

 

17. Buy baking supplies online from Michaels or Joann during free shipping promos.

a buy two get one free sign at michaels

Not only will your items ship free, but the online selection and sale prices for both stores’ cake decorating and baking supplies can’t be beat. Stock up on smaller supplies like sprinkles or cupcake liners when you see a “Buy 2 Get 1 Free” sale.

Once you’re signed up for store emails, you’ll be notified when free shipping promos begin.

If you’re already in the store, check the clearance bins at Joann. You’ll typically find some baking or cake-decorating items marked at least 30% off. I didn’t have any such luck at Michaels.

And if you love a good deal, don’t even bother looking for baking supplies at Hobby Lobby. These almost never go on sale.

TIP: Buy in person or do store pickup when you can. Hobby Lobby’s standard two-day shipping fee starts at $6.95 but is based on your order total and can go up to, literally, hundreds of dollars. Joann shipping fees are a little more favorable — they’re a whopping $10 usually, but you get free shipping if your order is $75+. Michaels shipping fees are the best of the cheapest craft store trifecta. It’s $8.95 for standard shipping from Michaels, but if your order is $50 or more you’ll get free shipping.

 

18. Aim for 50% savings on floral at all three retailers in the cheapest craft store list.

Hobby Lobby, Michaels, and Joann rotate floral sales based on the season, and all offer 50% off a variety of floral supplies, including plants, pots, floral wire, and twine. Call this one a three-way tie.

In a pinch, a 40% discount is acceptable.

 

19. Wait for 50% off rubber stamp supplies at Michaels and Hobby Lobby.

a person carrying a basket full of stamps from hobby lobby

In my opinion, Michaels’ selection of rubber stamps beats Hobby Lobby’s, but you’ll see 50% off sales at both craft stores.

 

20. Buy drawing and painting supplies at Michaels during BOGO 50% off sales.

These canvases and sketch pads are high quality. Look for BOGO 50% off sketch pads, canvases, pencils, paint, and any other artistic mediums you love.

If the brand of canvas doesn’t matter to you, every other week Hobby Lobby puts their Fine Touch two-pack canvases on sale for 40% off.

TIP: Wanna bring out your inner artist but also have no idea what you’re doing? Sign up for some free online classes.

 

 

21. Get quilting supplies at Joann and Hobby Lobby for 50% off.

You’ll find the best selection of high-quality scissors at Joann, though, which are also often marked 50% off.

 

22. Find the most durable storage solutions at Joann, but only buy when they’re 50% off.

storage bins at joann fabrics

While all three retailers on this cheapest craft store list offer storage solutions, I’ve found Joann to have the most durable, high-quality selection.

If you don’t see what you’re looking for in the store, opt for free in-store pickup with an online purchase, and use a coupon if your item isn’t already at least 50% off.

 

23. Buy home decor at Hobby Lobby when it’s 50% off.

If interior design is your craft, you already know Hobby Lobby has the best decor. Always wait for a 50% off sale. If it’s not on sale, stick it back on the shelf and wait a week.

 

My final tally shows Joann takes home the win without question, with Michaels and Hobby Lobby caught in a tie depending on what you need to buy. Disagree? Let me know where I should have awarded more points in the comments below. Thanks for reading.

Get our best deals on the go

By entering my phone number, I want to receive promotional messages from The Krazy Coupon Lady. Message frequency varies. Text STOP to 57299 to end or text HELP for help. Msg & data rates may apply. View Terms & Privacy.