We're reader-supported and only partner with brands we trust. When you buy through links on our site we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn More. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date and time indicated and are subject to change.
Easter is one of those holidays that I never stress about until the week prior. Of course that means I end up overspending and scrambling on marked-up candy or barely-in-stock basket stuffers that my kids forget about the next day. My goal is to change that in 2023, and I’m starting at Five Below. Easter is on April 9 this year, leaving me with a little bit of time to get my baskets in order without breaking my budget. What I love about Five Below Easter basket ideas is that there’s something useful for everyone and nothing feels like “junk.”
If you haven’t shopped at Five Below yet, just know that there is a $7.95 flat-rate shipping fee and you need to order by April 1 to ensure it comes in time. I avoid that fee by always choosing free store pickup, which is always 100% free. From Easter eggs, Five Below Squishmallows, and good deals on candy, we rounded up Five Below Easter finds into basket categories for easy shopping. Since many stores are closed on Easter, shop Five Below now to get ahead.
Download The Krazy Coupon Lady app for everything Easter, including DIY projects, recipes, and clearance deals.
Five Below Easter Basket Ideas
For the Kid Who Loves the Outdoors
Grab all these items for under $5 each and you have everything you need, including the sand bucket to put it all in, for $20 total.
For the Squishmallow-lover
Grab a $3 Easter basket and stuff it with what a Squish fan really wants this Easter: a $5.95 Squishmallow, Squishmallow Blind Bag, Squishmallow headphones, a Squishmallow bath bomb, and other fun goodies. For a grand total of $26.20, that’s pretty good. Especially considering a rare Easter Squishmallow at Target could cost you $14.99!
For the Beauty-lover
Skip the Sephora costs and find some serious beauty steals at Five Below, including a $2.50 hot stone massage kit, $5 blackhead extractor, and a $5 studded tumbler that is a perfect Starbucks studded tumbler dupe.
For the Funny Prankster of the Family
Always with a trick up their sleeve or a joke to share, these funny gifts are ideal for the prankster. You’ve got a snarky T-shirt, Prankz Fun Lil’ Hands set, Oscar Mayer gummy bacon, Pictionary, and a beanie. Perfecto!
For the Big Kids/Teens Easter Basket
Got a big kid or teen in your life? Here’s the Easter basket for them! You can’t go wrong with a Taco Bell Crunchwrap float, Bluetooth ear buds, and a Nickelodeon Coffee mug cocoa set.