October means celebrating the spooky season with all the pumpkin spice products, but if you want to level up your festivities and match all your Halloween decorations, you should pick up a pumpkin-shaped Halloween pizza throughout October. Lucky for you, we found all the restaurants we expect to be selling pumpkin-shaped or jack-o’-lantern pizza in 2024 based on last year’s deals.
And then mark your calendars for February because that’s when you can find a heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s. We know … it totally makes the pizza taste better.
TIP: October is also National Pizza Month, so you’ll be able to get pizza deals all month long.
Aldi Ghost/Pumpkin Halloween Pizza was $4.99 — 9% cheaper from 2022 to 2023.
There were plenty of Aldi deals for you to get year-round, but one of the best seasonal deals was the Aldi Halloween Pizza. You were able to pick up the two Halloween-themed pizzas: one in a ghost shape, as well as a pumpkin-shaped pizza for $4.99 each in 2023, which was 9% cheaper than the price in 2022.
Both give a festive feel, but the ghost shaped pizza used mozzarella cheese and the pumpkin shaped pizza used cheddar cheese.
Papa John’s offered their 11-inch Pumpkin-Shaped Pizza for $11 — the same price from 2022 to 2023.
Papa John’s Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza was only $10.99, making this one of the only pizza items that wasn’t affected by pricing increases in the past few years. You received a pepperoni-lined crust, a pepperoni mouth, and pepperoni and olive eyes on an 11-inch pumpkin-shaped thin crust pizza.
This pizza was offered from Oct. 23 to 31, 2023, and it was cheaper than ordering a medium pepperoni pizza (regularly $14.89) by 26.2%. The only downside was that you’ll get fewer pepperoni slices with their Jack-O’-Lantern pizza.
Papa Murphy’s Pumpkin-Shaped ‘Jack-O Pizza’ started at $10 — 16% cheaper than a regular pizza.
Papa Murphy’s was offering their annual “Jack-O Pizza” throughout October, ending on Halloween, Oct. 31, 2023. It was one of our favorite Papa Murphy’s take n bake pizza deals of the entire year. You could have grabbed their 16-inch “Jack-O Pizza” for $13 and their 14-inch “Jack-O Pizza” for $10.
Both sizes of pizza were pumpkin shaped, with pepperoni around the edge of the pizza and forming the face. Two olives accentuate the eyes.
Each Papa Murphy’s Halloween pizza cost $2 less than the nonseasonal versions of the same sized pizza. (For example, the 16-inch pepperoni pizza costs $15). However, you wouldn’t get as much pepperoni as a regular pepperoni pizza.
Casey’s Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza was until Halloween at a price of $13.99 — the same price from 2022 to 2023.
In Oct. 2023, you were able to grab a Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza from Casey’s for $13.99. This festive pizza pie came with a pepperoni smile and olive eyes. These pizzas were available until Oct. 31.
If you were a member of the Casey’s Rewards program, you got double rewards points on all your pumpkin-shaped pizza purchases.
Peter Piper Pizza’s Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza was $18.98 — the same price as a large pizza in 2023.
In Oct. 2023, Peter Piper Pizza sold their Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza for $18.98. These pizzas were available until Oct. 31, 2023, and you could have even ordered it as a combo with their Halloween Crunch Dessert (regularly $7.99) for $21.99 — a 18.5% discount.
If you were just looking to get the pizza by itself, just know that the Jack-O’-Lantern Pizza will cost the same as a large pepperoni pizza in 2023, which meant you were paying the same amount for less pepperoni.
Chuck E. Cheese Pumpkin-Shaped Halloween Pizza was $23.58 — a 30% increase from 2022 to 2023.
If you visited a Chuck E. Cheese in October 2023, you could have grabbed a 14-inch pumpkin- shaped Halloween pizza for $23.58. Each pizza had a pepperoni border with olive eyes. In 2022, the price was $16.49, so you would have paid 30.1% more than last year. There were even more Halloween-themed treats that you could have gotten at Chuck E. Cheese during the Spooky Season:
- Creepy Cupcakes ($5.49) — a vanilla cupcake with edible slime on top.
- Slime Cookie ($8.79) — a giant pizza cookie that has edible slime on top.
- Dippin’ Dots Eye Scream ($6.00) — Dippin’ Dots with gummy worms sticking out of it with edible slime and a gummy eye on top.
Plus, if you brought a costumed kid to a Chuck E. Cheese location, you could have gotten 100 free E-tickets everyday in October, and free candy was offered at 6:30 p.m., 7:30 p.m., and 8:30 p.m. everyday in October 2023.